In December 2018 an analytics manager in financial services sent me her competency grid. Against almost every line she had rated herself 1 out of 4. Her peer, who had watched her work every day, gave her 3s and 4s.
That sheet changed what we measured in that engagement. It also changed how I think about the return on coaching. Before anyone asks “what did we get for the money?”, someone has to ask “where does this leader actually stand, and who says so?”
The cases below are real and masked. No client is named. Where a figure was told to us rather than measured by us, we say so. The figures for the practice as a whole, and their limits, are set out on Evidence and methodology.
Three ledgers, not one
Coaching returns value to three parties, and each keeps its own ledger. Mixing them is where most ROI claims go wrong.
| Ledger | Who reads it | What goes in it | How it is evidenced |
|---|---|---|---|
| Return to the organisation | CFO, business head | Movement in agreed business measures: turnaround time, quality score, audit findings, team output | The organisation's own MIS, before and after, with an honest share credited to coaching |
| Return on the sponsor's expectation | Reporting manager, CHRO | Did we get the leader we needed: the successor who is ready, the manager who now delegates | The sponsor's judgement, written down at the start and asked again at the close |
| Return to the leader | The coachee | Readiness for the next role, promotion, compensation | Ratings by others, role movement, and compensation as the leader reports it |
A sponsor who pays for coaching is buying from the first two ledgers. A leader who pays for themselves is buying from the third. Most of our coachees paid for themselves; organisations sponsored the rest. So we have had to keep all three honestly, and not let a figure from one ledger pass as proof for another.
The method we have used since 2018
Every engagement starts with the role, not the person. In our first mail to a new coachee in 2018 the instruction was plain: start from the job description, the skills it needs, the ideal level and the industry benchmark. Only then look at where you stand.
We put that on one sheet, first called the Competency Self-assessment Grid and from 2019 N-GAGE, Nirvedha's Goal Achievement Grid Enabler.
- The leader names two to four goals. Each becomes a broad skill area with a weight; the weights add to 100%.
- Each area splits into elementary competencies, again weighted to 100%.
- For every competency the leader writes the critical task, the standard or benchmark, how it will be assessed, the evidence today, and the gap.
- Three ratings, each on a 1 to 4 scale: the leader's own, a peer's (later the senior's too), and the benchmark for the role.
- The sheet rolls these up into one figure per rater. We called it Present Job Market Value; in CoachOS today it is the Role Readiness Index.
One row from a 2023 engagement shows what “evidence” means here:
| Competency | Critical task | Standard | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Industry knowledge | Disbursement processing with maximum quality and least turnaround | Disbursal in 3 hours, loan booking in 1 hour, quality score 95% | Monthly MIS shows the turnaround; quality scorecard averages 95% |
The evidence column is where coaching meets the business. It ties a behaviour to a number the organisation already counts.
The first finding: the gap between self and others
The first number worth having is not a business number. It is the distance between how leaders rate themselves and how the people around them rate them. In our grids that gap runs both ways, and it is large.
Case A rated herself 31% ready. Her peer put her at 65%, above the benchmark for her role. She was not short of skill; she was short of belief, and it showed most in the very thing she wanted to grow, telling stories with data. Coaching her on technique would have wasted the fee.
Case B rated himself 97%. His peer put him at 80%, and the role benchmark sat at 89%. The gap was widest in innovation and adaptability. On time management, the area he had chosen to work on, all three ratings agreed.
Without the second and third rating, both engagements would have been aimed at the wrong target.
That is the first return a sponsor gets: coaching pointed at the right gap.
From the gap to action
A gap on a sheet changes nothing until it becomes a dated action that someone can see done. Our sequence has stayed the same since 2018.
- Goals, made sharp. We mine, refine, define and then “shine” each goal into one line of eight to ten words, with its measure inside it.
- Strategies. Five to eight per goal, put in a sensible order. A goal without strategies is still a wish.
- Time-bound actions. Each strategy gets an action, an owner, a date, a status and the date it was actually done.
- Weekly tracking. A simple tracker, week by week, that the leader fills and the coach reads before each session.
- A second rating. The peer and the senior rate again, and we read the new gap.
Case B shows how quickly this moves when the gap is agreed. Within three weeks he had six actions on prioritisation and delegation, all marked implemented between 20 March and 10 April 2023:
| Competency | Strategy | What he did |
|---|---|---|
| Work prioritisation | One slot for all | A fixed daily slot for routine queries from his teams |
| Work prioritisation | Time-bound discussions | Time limits on meetings, one issue settled at a time |
| Work prioritisation | Work listing | His daily schedule shared with his direct reports and his own manager |
| Delegation | Break down tasks | Work split by responsibility and handed to the right person |
| Delegation | Single point of contact | One owner made answerable for each task |
| Delegation | Directing people | Cross-team queries sent to the process owner, not to him |
He also drew a delegation chart and brought his own boss into it. That is the system getting ready for the change, not only the leader.
Putting a number on it
A return is only a return once the fee is taken off. Many coaching ROI claims stop at the benefit and never show what was paid. We show both, and we discount the benefit before we count it.
The discount follows Jack Phillips' ROI Methodology. The people who saw the change are asked two questions: what share of this improvement came from the coaching, and how sure are you of that share? Both answers reduce the figure.
| Step | Illustrative figure |
|---|---|
| Improvement in the agreed business measure over the year, valued by finance | ₹40 lakh |
| Share the sponsor and peers attribute to coaching (average) | 40% |
| Their confidence in that share (average) | 60% |
| Benefit credited to coaching: 40 × 40% × 60% | ₹9.6 lakh |
| Coaching fee, six months | ₹5 lakh |
| Net return: 9.6 − 5 | ₹4.6 lakh |
| ROI: net return ÷ fee | 92% |
These figures are an example, not a client result. The point is the shape: a modest, traceable number that a CFO can check line by line is worth more than a large one borrowed from a published study.
Two rules keep it honest. The business measure is agreed and baselined before the first session, from the organisation's own MIS. And it must be a measure the leader can actually move; if it depends mostly on policy or on another function, it measures the organisation, not the leader.
The third ledger, told honestly
Across the 103 leaders in our promotion cohort, the annual salary increase each reported at the point of promotion adds up to ₹32 Crore (USD $3.8M+). That is the return to the leader, and for those who paid their own fee it is the return that mattered most.
We hold that figure to the same standard as the rest of this paper, so here is what it is and what it is not.
- It is reported by the leaders themselves. Each told us their compensation before and after, in the course of the engagement. It is not checked against payroll.
- It is a total, before any discount. Promotions have many causes: the market, the employer, the leader's own work. No share has been taken off for coaching, so it is not an ROI, and it describes an observed change, not a caused one.
- It belongs to the leader's ledger only. It says nothing on its own about what a sponsoring organisation got back.
Why share it at all? Because a number the leaders themselves gave us, across 103 people, is a real signal. It is just not proof, and we will not present it as proof. The full definition, window and exclusions are on Evidence and methodology.
The better practice is to record compensation at the start, with the leader's consent, and ask again a year after the last session.
Durability: measure the half-life, not just the peak
The reading that counts comes a year after the coach has left. Leadership behaviour is like any other capital: it wears down unless someone maintains it.
Case A shows this from the inside. In 2018 her grid caught a leader who undervalued herself by more than 30 points. She grew, moved on, and came back to us in 2025 for a new transition into sales and business development in AI. Her 2025 goals again included dropping self-doubt and communicating with confidence. The skill had grown; the old belief had come back under a new kind of pressure.
That is not a failure of the first engagement. It is what change looks like over seven years. But it tells a sponsor something a close-out report cannot: some gains hold, some need maintaining, and you only learn which by asking again later.
So we add one date to the contract: a stakeholder pulse 12 months after the last session, using the same grid and the same raters. If the change is still visible to the team, that is the return confirmed. If it has faded, it tells the sponsor the system around the leader was never ready, and that is worth knowing too.
An honest note on our own record: our grids hold strong starting and mid-point ratings. Full end-of-engagement and 12-month rescores are the part we have done least well, and the part we most need to strengthen.
Ethics and confidentiality
Measurement gives the sponsor visibility. It must not give the sponsor the coaching room.
- The sponsor sees numbers and actions, never the conversation. Ratings, the agreed gap, the actions and their status go into a sponsor report. What the leader said about fear, family or a difficult boss does not.
- The leader sees the report first. Nothing goes to the sponsor until the coachee has read and approved it.
- Peers rate behaviour, not character. Raters are chosen with the leader, briefed on what they are rating, and their individual scores are not shown to the sponsor.
- One leader's sheet is never another's template. Every grid starts blank. A filled sheet holds evidence and ratings about a named person, and it stays with that engagement.
- No names in public. Every case here is masked, and so is every case we publish.
On putting a share of the fee at risk against results: it can sharpen focus, and some buyers ask for it. It can also pull the coach towards the sponsor's number and away from what the leader actually needs, as Case A shows: her real gap was belief, not a business metric. Where any fee is at risk, the measures and the raters must be agreed by all three parties at the start, and the coach must keep the right to say a measure belongs to the system, not the leader.
A protocol for sponsors and coaches
Most of the measurement happens before the first session. Everything after it is reading the same grid again, with the same people.
We built CoachOS so that a coach does not have to rely on spreadsheets passed around by email, as we did from 2018. The grid, the three-party agreement, the actions and the sponsor report sit in one record per engagement. The sponsor report goes out only after the leader approves it. The method stands without the software; the software just makes it hard to skip a step.
The question for the sponsor
The analytics manager in Case A did not need more skill. She needed someone to show her the gap between her own rating and her peer's. The operations head in Case B did not need more confidence. He needed the same sheet to show him the opposite gap.
In both, the most valuable number was cheap to collect, and it came before a single coaching hour was spent.
So before you ask your coach what return you will get, ask yourself one question. Do you know how the leader you are about to invest in rates themselves, and how far that is from what their team sees?
If you don't, you are not yet ready to measure the return. You are only ready to argue about it later.